When Madge died last spring, I thought the secrets of our family had died with her. At her funeral, however, Dewitt, the man I had loved as a teenager, asked me a question that changed everything. “Why didn’t you ever write me back?” he asked. My daughter immediately grabbed my arm and whispered, “Mama, people will talk.”
When I was seventeen, Dewitt taught me to drive his father’s hay truck. We spent long summer afternoons together, laughing and dreaming about the future. I gave him my class ring, which he wore on a shoelace beneath his shirt. I believed we had something special.
When I left for nursing school in Sacramento, I wrote him fourteen letters on pink paper. I waited for his replies, but nothing arrived. Eventually, I heard through my sister Madge that Dewitt was seeing someone else. I was heartbroken, but I eventually married a wonderful man named Alvis and built a life with him.
Years later, I discovered that Madge had married Dewitt. I never understood why he had stopped communicating with me, but pride prevented me from asking. We spent decades attending family gatherings, pretending our shared past was nothing more than an old memory.
After Madge’s funeral, Dewitt revealed something shocking. He said he had written to me every week, but Madge had told him I wanted nothing more to do with him. The following morning, I visited his ranch to find out the truth.
When I entered his house, I saw a bundle of pink envelopes on the table. They were my fourteen letters, along with all the letters Dewitt had written but never sent. Hidden among them was a handwritten confession from Madge admitting that she had intercepted our correspondence because she wanted Dewitt for herself.
I was devastated and angry. Dewitt admitted that he had loved Madge, despite never knowing what she had done. I realized that one person’s jealousy had changed both our lives. My daughter eventually understood why I needed the truth, even if other people judged me.
Before leaving, I invited Dewitt to have coffee sometime. He smiled and accepted. I took my old letters home, finally understanding that it was never a lack of love that separated us. It was a lie we had both believed for more than fifty years.