A new development in the case of Charlie Kirk’s murder suggests a possible political motive. Utah County Attorney Jeff Gray revealed that Tyler Robinson, 22, left a note for his transgender roommate stating, “I had the chance to kill Charlie Kirk, and I’m going to do it.” Robinson also wrote that he believed Kirk hated him.

After the news broke, prominent conservatives denied that Robinson had ties to right-wing groups. Instead, they pointed to rhetoric from the political left, arguing that years of hostile language against conservatives may have contributed to the violence.

This debate quickly moved into mainstream media. On Fox News’ The Five, co-hosts clashed over the meaning of Kirk’s death. Greg Gutfeld strongly opposed Jessica Tarlov’s view that the case should be seen as part of a wider pattern of political violence on both sides.

Gutfeld argued that Kirk’s murder was different, both in its motive and in the attention it received. He said that public criticism of figures like Kirk had created a more hostile environment for conservatives.

Tarlov, however, pointed out other violent acts targeting Democrats. She argued that political violence is not confined to one party. But Gutfeld refused to draw comparisons, insisting Kirk’s case stood apart.

According to Gutfeld, extreme beliefs and divisive rhetoric can radicalize individuals. He said Robinson was likely influenced by online narratives that distort morality and encourage dehumanization.

Tarlov clarified that she was not minimizing Kirk’s death. Still, Gutfeld insisted the conversation should avoid the “both sides” framing, which he saw as diminishing the seriousness of the case.

He concluded by calling for accountability, arguing that society must reject toxic ideas and rhetoric that lead to violence.