Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani, a 34-year-old democratic socialist, celebrated his narrow victory in Brooklyn after defeating former Governor Andrew Cuomo and Republican Curtis Sliwa with just over 50% of the vote. His campaign focused on affordability, free public services, and economic equality, yet his victory party appeared to contradict those promises.

Held at the newly renovated Brooklyn Paramount, a historic music venue, Mamdani’s celebration featured a cash bar with notably high prices. Drinks ranged from $13 for beer to $22 for cocktails, while soft drinks and snacks also came at premium costs. Photos of the menu quickly spread online, sparking criticism and ridicule.

Commentators and political opponents seized on the apparent irony of a self-proclaimed advocate for working-class New Yorkers hosting an event with upscale bar prices. Many accused the mayor-elect of hypocrisy, suggesting that his campaign promises of “free” public services were undermined by the high costs at his own party.

While campaign events often operate as cash bars, Mamdani’s critics noted that his rivals offered more generous accommodations. Cuomo’s event featured an open bar despite his loss, while Sliwa’s team provided free food and drink tickets to guests. Mamdani’s supporters, in contrast, paid for everything themselves except for the celebratory atmosphere.

The Brooklyn Paramount, newly reopened as a Live Nation property, added another layer of irony for critics. Once a landmark for jazz icons like Ella Fitzgerald, the venue now symbolizes commercial entertainment—an odd choice for a politician who campaigns against corporate influence and economic inequality.

Beyond the controversy, the episode raised broader questions about Mamdani’s ability to deliver on his ambitious agenda. His proposals for free childcare, rent freezes, and free buses will require approval from state leaders, while opponents warn his tax-based funding model could drive wealth away from New York City.