After Doctors Misdiagnosed Her with a Cold, a 5-Year-Old Girl Died from a Treatable Illness Common in Children

Cassie, a bright and energetic five-year-old, lost her voice just days after falling ill. Initially dismissed as a mild viral infection, her symptoms—sore throat and raspy voice—did not alarm doctors. Her parents, Jasmine and Justin Sutton, were advised to monitor her at home. No throat swab was taken, and no antibiotics were prescribed.

Despite their growing concern, Cassie’s condition worsened rapidly. Within days, she struggled to breathe, and her parents rushed her to the emergency room. Again, tests for COVID-19 and RSV were negative, and once more, she was sent home without further investigation. Her illness, however, was not viral—it was strep A, a common but dangerous bacterial infection in children, easily diagnosed with a simple throat swab.

Cassie’s health collapsed at home. Her lips turned blue, and she lost consciousness. Paramedics airlifted her to Westmead Children’s Hospital, where doctors performed 78 minutes of CPR, but it was too late. Only then was a throat swab taken, confirming the presence of Group A Streptococcus. The infection, left untreated, proved fatal.

Cassie’s death was preventable. Her parents are devastated—not just by her loss, but by the missed opportunities to save her through standard medical procedures. Globally, strep A affects millions each year but is frequently overlooked, especially in children. Cassie’s case highlights the need for more rigorous attention in pediatric diagnosis.

Now, her family advocates for awareness. They urge parents to trust their instincts and push for testing. Cassie’s story, though heartbreaking, is a call to action—to listen, to test, and to protect children like her.